Quick Answer: Does This Renovation Pay For Itself?
The calculator gives two percentages, because the industry and finance use different ones. Cost recouped % = Value Added ÷ Effective Cost × 100 is the figure Cost vs. Value reports publish: 100% means you get every dollar back at resale. ROI % = (Value Added − Effective Cost) ÷ Effective Cost × 100 is the return on the money spent: 0% means you break even, above 0% means the project adds more resale value than it cost, and below 0% means part of the spend is paying for enjoyment or necessity, not investment return. Effective Cost accounts for any DIY labor savings.
Quick reference (Cost vs. Value 2025 national averages, contractor-installed): minor kitchen remodel: $28,458 cost, $32,141 value added, 113% cost recouped (a 13% ROI), the best-performing interior project nationally. Midrange bathroom remodel: $26,138 cost, $20,910 value added, 80% recouped (−20% ROI). Upscale kitchen remodel: roughly 31% recouped (−69% ROI). Upscale bathroom remodel: roughly 42% recouped (−58% ROI). The pattern is consistent across categories: modest, functional updates recoup far more of their cost than luxury upgrades of the same room type.
This gap is the single most important thing this calculator makes visible: a $161,000 upscale kitchen and a $28,458 minor kitchen refresh are not different sizes of the same good decision, they're financially opposite decisions if resale value is your primary goal.