Quick Answer — Which Kind of Down Payment Assistance Is Worth Most?
Assistance comes in four structures, and the headline dollar amount tells you almost nothing about what it is worth. A grant is never repaid. A forgivable second is written off over a residency period. A deferred loan is repaid in full when you sell or refinance. A repayable second amortises monthly like any other loan.
A $340,000 home with $10,200 of your own money (3 percent) and $15,000 of assistance, at a 6.5 percent first mortgage rate over 30 years with 0.55 percent annual mortgage insurance:
- Down payment rises from 3.0 percent to 7.41 percent
- First mortgage falls from $329,800 to $314,800
- Loan-to-value falls from 97.0 to 92.59 percent
- Monthly cost falls from $2,235.72 to $2,134.03 — $101.69 less
- First-mortgage interest saved over seven years — $6,526
What it is worth depends entirely on the structure and how long you stay. A grant is worth $15,578 including mortgage insurance saved. A five-year forgivable second is worth the same $15,578 if you stay seven years, and only $9,248 if you leave after three — a $6,330 cliff sitting between two perfectly ordinary outcomes.